How easy is it to get ripped off in property? I know I can be quite naive and overly trusting. I’ve always gone into every purchase assuming that whoever I’m dealing with has been straightforward and that everything has been disclosed. And 95% of the time, maybe 99%, that’s true. But 40 plus years in property have taught me that it isn’t always.
A brilliant example comes from a day I spent in Manchester, many years ago, before I’d even bought my first buy to let. What looked like an amazing opportunity was unravelled in a single conversation, which I wasn’t even part of.
The show home
I was still planning how to start my property business, and where to buy. A friend of mine, a seasoned property professional who’d grown up in Manchester, was interested when I told him I was going to meet a firm that regularly advertised properties there. As far as I could see it fitted what we’d now call the BRR model: buy, refurbish, refinance.
Nowadays we’d call them deal sourcers or deal packagers. The advert said they were selling properties from a portfolio that was being broken up. I’m not going to name them, because if they’re still around they’ll know who I’m talking about.
We went up one Friday, and one of their people met us at the station and drove us out to a very nice terraced house in what seemed to be a lovely leafy suburb. I knew it was a cheaper area because I could see the asking prices, but the house had been refurbished to a really good standard. We were told it was pre-let and the tenant was moving in the following Monday. They said all their properties were done to this standard, and if we were interested they’d source them, refurb them, let them and manage them. The all-in cost, as far as I remember, was about £30,000 a property. Don’t worry about the figures, it’s the principle I’m trying to get across.
The phone call in the car
After the inspection we got back in the car, and a member of staff was driving us back to the station when his mobile rang. It was the boss from the office, and the call was on speakerphone so we could hear it, and I’m sure that was deliberate.
The gist of it was: are they still with you? If they are, tell them that if they’ll commit to buying three today, we’ll knock an extra £5,000 off each property, or £7,500, or whatever the figure was. The member of staff dutifully asked, do you want to commit now? We said thank you, but no thank you. He dropped us at the station, and I went home.
What the estate agent told my friend
My friend decided to stay on and visit Memory Lane. But first he walked back to where we’d been taken and went into a local estate agent very close to the house, to find out what the area and the prices were really like.
At some point the agent said, have you just been to see that house up the road? Did such and such a firm take you there? My friend said yes. And the agent said, in that case you do need to be careful, and he completely opened up.
It turned out that house was their show home. They’d done it up to an excellent standard, and according to the story there was always a tenant moving in next week, but nobody ever moved in. It was the property they always showed to potential clients. The ones they actually sold were nothing like it, apparently, and the refurbs were nowhere near that standard. Quite shoddy, in fact. And the agent asked, did they drive you there through all these tree-lined streets? Go and look at the parallel streets, he said, and you’ll see lots of boarded up properties which nobody wants to buy, and for good reason. The route from the station is very carefully planned so it looks like a lovely leafy suburb.
Then he dropped the bombshell. If you do want properties like that, don’t buy from them. They’ll charge you £25,000 or £30,000, but register with us and we regularly have properties ready for a refurb that you can buy for around £15,000. Even with the refurb you wouldn’t pay much more than £20,000.
I’m not saying that agent was a saint. For all I know he wanted the business himself. But he had no reason to protect the people who’d just driven us around, and if we’d been thinking of buying one, and we weren’t, because we smelt a rat anyway, he’d just saved us an awful lot of money and grief. What we’d been told didn’t make sense, and a complete stranger up the road had given us enough of the real story not to do anything reckless.
So who can you trust?
I wasn’t surprised, to be honest. At that time there were a lot of disreputable property sourcers doing very similar things: buying cheap properties up north and selling them, mainly to investors in London, for two, three or four times the price, which still looked cheap to somebody from the South East. I think the industry is much cleaner today. But we can’t be naive, and within the last few years I know people who bought from very convincing sourcers and lost an awful lot of money. Hopefully the bad ones are a minority, and I’m sure there are many very good ones.
But who can you trust? Clearly not just anybody because they’re friendly, which if I’m honest is one of the mistakes I’ve made in the past. And you can’t trust somebody because the house they show you is lovely, with a promise that all their properties are like that.
So do your due diligence. If you’re dealing with a deal sourcer, first make sure they comply with the regulations. A properly run deal sourcing business must be registered with a redress scheme such as the Property Ombudsman. They should be registered for anti-money laundering with HMRC, they should be working within the Estate Agents Act, and they should have professional indemnity insurance. If they really want your business, they should be happy to tell you and to prove it if you ask, without taking offence.
If someone offers you a property at a network meeting and it seems too good to be true, do your due diligence on the person and the property before you commit. Go and look at it, and then do what my friend did. Walk the area. Talk to local estate agents. Find out what properties sell for locally in that unrefurbished condition. Ask the other investors at the meeting what they think. And a simple scroll through Rightmove, Zoopla or OnTheMarket might show you that the prices you’re being quoted are completely out of kilter with what’s going on locally.
You’d be surprised how many people, even now, buy properties blind without really looking, and it all ends up as tears at bedtime. But that doesn’t need to be you or me.
Here’s to successful property inspecting.
Peter Jones
Author, property investor and ex-Chartered Surveyor




